The first time you run payroll, it feels like there should be a single button. There almost is, modern payroll software does the math. But before you get to the button, there's setup that decides whether you're compliant or quietly accumulating penalties. Here's the whole thing in order.
Before your first payroll
Get your employer tax IDs
You need a federal EIN from the IRS (free, takes minutes online), and you need to register with your state's tax and labor agencies for state withholding and unemployment insurance accounts. If you have employees in more than one state, you register in each state where someone works. This is the step people skip, and skipping it means running payroll out of compliance from the first check.
Classify every worker correctly
Before anyone gets paid, confirm each person is correctly an employee or a contractor, and for employees, whether they're exempt or non-exempt from overtime. Getting this wrong is the most expensive payroll mistake there is, and payroll software will not catch it for you.
Collect the paperwork
Each new hire needs a completed Form W-4 (so you withhold the right federal tax) and a Form I-9 (employment eligibility, due within three business days of their start). Set up direct deposit details and any benefit deductions.
Running the payroll itself
- Pick a schedule and stick to it. Weekly, biweekly, or semi-monthly. Some states set minimum pay frequencies, so check yours.
- Calculate gross pay, then withholdings. Federal income tax, Social Security and Medicare (FICA), state income tax where it applies, and any benefit or garnishment deductions. Payroll software handles this once setup is right.
- Pay employees and remit the taxes. This is the part people forget: withholding the taxes is not the same as paying them to the government. You have to deposit federal and state payroll taxes on a schedule, and file the returns.
The deadlines that carry penalties
Payroll tax deposits are due on a set schedule (often semi-weekly or monthly depending on your size), and late deposits trigger penalties that add up fast. You also file quarterly federal returns (Form 941) and annual forms (W-2s to employees by January 31, plus state filings). The IRS employment tax guidance lays out the schedules. Missing these is the most common way a small business racks up avoidable penalties.
Software helps, but it is not the whole job
Gusto, Rippling, and similar tools run the calculations and file taxes once configured. But they do not register you in new states, decide classifications, catch a missing I-9, or tell you that your multi-state setup is incomplete. The software is the engine; the setup and the judgment are still on you.
The bottom line
Running payroll is: register with the right tax agencies, classify workers correctly, collect the forms, pay on a consistent schedule, and remit and file the taxes on time. The calculations are easy; the setup and deadlines are where it breaks. Bevel HR sets up payroll correctly and coordinates it so you never miss a deposit or a filing.
Written by the Bevel HR team, 10+ years of HR inside startups, SaaS, and Fortune 500 brands. Bevel HR provides HR consulting, not legal advice.